OldRoll vs. Fimo: Full Vintage Film Camera Comparação
OldRoll and Fimo take opposite approaches to charging for film simulation: OldRoll sells one subscription that unlocks its entire camera library, while Fimo sells access to its Pro tier for $29.99/year and then charges $0.99–$1.99 per individual film pack on top of that. If you want more than a couple of specific film looks, OldRoll’s all-in-one model is very likely the cheaper path.
Two Different Monetization Models
This is the single biggest difference between the apps, more than any look or feature. OldRoll’s yearly plan ($12.99–$19.99) unlocks every camera in the library at once — there’s no additional a la carte purchasing once you’re subscribed. Fimo’s Pro subscription ($29.99/year) gets you into the app’s pro tier, but individual film stocks — named packs like GOLD 200, Morandi200, Portra 160NC, and others — are then purchased separately at $0.99–$1.99 each. A handful of reviewers have referenced a roughly $90 lifetime option for Fimo, though it isn’t consistently listed in the app’s current pricing structure, so confirm directly in-app before assuming it’s available.
| OldRoll | Fimo | |
|---|---|---|
| Base yearly cost | $12.99–$19.99 (everything included) | $29.99 (Pro tier only) |
| Individual content | None — all cameras included in subscription | $0.99–$1.99 per film pack, purchased separately |
| Classificação | 4.5 stars, 212,000+ reviews (Google Play) | 4.0 stars, 258 ratings (App Store) |
| Desenvolvimento | accordion (Guangzhou) | Guangzhou Hongxiao Network Technology Co., Ltd. |
What This Means in Practice
If you only ever want to shoot with two or three specific film stocks, Fimo’s a la carte model can actually work out cheaper than a full OldRoll subscription — you’re not paying for a large library you won’t use. But the moment you want to experiment across five, ten, or more film looks, the individual purchases in Fimo add up fast, and OldRoll’s flat-rate model becomes the clear value pick.
Fimo’s much smaller App Store rating count (258 versus OldRoll’s 212,000+ on Google Play) is also worth factoring in — it doesn’t necessarily mean lower quality, but it does mean there’s a smaller public track record to judge the app by compared to OldRoll’s much larger user base.
Camera and Film Library Size
OldRoll’s subscription unlocks a large and continually growing library of camera presets — disposable-camera looks, 90s point-and-shoot styles, VHS-style video filters, and a range of film stocks modeled after real-world emulsions. Because everything sits behind one subscription, new cameras that get added to the app become available to existing subscribers automatically, with no extra purchase required. Fimo’s library is built around named film packs (GOLD 200, Morandi200, Portra 160NC, and others) that are added to the Pro tier’s catalog over time, but each one is priced and sold individually, so growth in the library doesn’t automatically translate into more value for a subscriber who hasn’t bought those specific packs.
For someone who likes to experiment broadly — trying a disposable-camera look one day and a moody film-noir edit the next — that structural difference matters more than any single feature comparison. OldRoll’s subscribers can freely switch between the full catalog; Fimo users are effectively curating a smaller, purchased collection unless they’re willing to keep buying new packs.
Interface and Editing Tools
Both apps are built around a similar core workflow: pick a camera or film look, shoot or import a photo, and apply date stamps, light leaks, grain, and other analog-style effects. OldRoll leans into a simple, one-tap capture-and-apply flow that keeps the emphasis on speed — open the app, choose a camera, shoot. Fimo’s Pro tier adds a bit more manual control over some effects within a purchased film pack, which can appeal to users who want to fine-tune grain intensity or light-leak placement rather than accept a fixed preset look. Neither app currently positions itself as a full manual-editing suite in the way a dedicated photo editor would; both are meant to apply an authentic, ready-to-share analog aesthetic quickly rather than to replace granular manual controls.
Who Should Choose Which App
OldRoll makes the most sense for anyone who wants to explore a wide range of vintage and film-camera looks without tracking individual purchases — students, casual social posters, and anyone who just wants to open an app and shoot without thinking about what they’ve already bought. Fimo can make sense for someone who has already identified two or three specific film stocks they love and doesn’t expect to need much beyond that, since the Pro tier plus a small number of packs can undercut a full-year OldRoll subscription in that narrow case. Outside of that narrow case, most users comparing total cost across a full year of casual use will find OldRoll’s flat subscription the simpler and usually cheaper option.
Common Mistakes When Comparing Them
- Assuming Fimo’s $29.99 gets you everything. It gets you into the Pro tier; specific film packs are typically still purchased individually on top of that.
- Not counting up how many film packs you’d actually want before deciding Fimo is cheaper — three or four individual purchases can quickly exceed the cost of an OldRoll subscription.
- Relying on a mentioned lifetime price without confirming it’s currently offered — in-app purchase structures change, so check the live purchase screen rather than older reviews.
Perguntas Mais Frequentes
Which app has more realistic film simulation, OldRoll or Fimo?
Both are well-regarded for their film simulation quality; the honest answer is that “more realistic” comes down to which specific film stocks you’re trying to emulate, so testing both on the same photo is the most reliable way to judge for your own eye.
Can I try Fimo’s films before buying them?
Purchase policies for individual film packs are set by the app and can change, so check the current listing for each film pack in Fimo directly rather than assuming a preview or trial is available.
Is OldRoll’s subscription really cheaper overall?
For anyone who wants access to more than a handful of film looks, yes — OldRoll’s flat yearly fee covers the entire camera library, while Fimo’s per-film pricing scales up the more variety you want.
Do both apps work on both iPhone and Android?
Yes, both OldRoll and Fimo are available on the Apple App Store and Google Play, though specific camera or film availability can vary slightly by platform and app version.
Leitura Relacionada
See our full Revisão OldRoll for a complete features breakdown, or browse the wider field in our OldRoll alternatives roundup.
